For Medical Professionals
Clinical Competency Committees (CCC)
Graduate Medical Education (GME)
NCH Department of Medical Education and its training programs are committed to conduct meaningful assessments of their trainees based on multiple sources including formative and summative evaluations, milestones-based assessments based on direct observation, simulation, rating scale, evaluation of scholarly work, and 360 degrees evaluation in compliance with the ACGME requirements. These assessments are meant to provide meaningful performance evaluation and feedback to allow to the program director to design an individualized learning plan aimed at strengthening areas of weakness.
In accordance with the ACGME requirements, each training program is expected to form a Clinical Competency Committee (CCC). The program director appoints the CCC. The CCC must have at least three program core faculty (excluding the program director) who have the opportunity to observe and evaluate the residents. CCC members may also include non-physician members of the health care team, non-MD educators, assessment specialists, or residents in their final year. For example, a small fellowship program may include faculty from the core program or from required rotations in other specialties.
Description of CCC meetings:
- The CCC meets at least semi-annually to review and discuss each individual residents’ performance data (one year programs might need to meet more frequently to give meaningful assessments but they have less number of trainees)
- The program director (PD) and the GME department will prepare Milestones data summary on each resident through reports generated from various sources e.g. 360-degree evaluations, rotation evaluations, Simulations, etc…
- In some situations the residents’ data will be divided among CCC members to review before the meeting and report on during the meeting
- The role of the CCC is to make a consensus decision on the progress of each resident by applying assessment data to the milestones.
- The CCC serves as an early warning system/early identification if a resident fails to progress in the educational program and make recommendations to the program director for resident progress including promotion, remediation, and dismissal.
- Each resident is given a semi-annual assessment on a dashboard in one of the following 5 categories on each of the metrics set by the program: (No Data, Below Expected for training level, Needs Improvement, On Track for training level, Above Expected for training level).
- The CCC will generate a report/ recommendation letter to PD on each resident. The PD will meet with each resident and communicate the recommendation, design an improvement plan, etc..
- Thresholds will be set by the CCC. Interventions a program might consider include assigning a mentor with expertise in a given area of deficiency, additional required readings, sessions in a skills lab, and/or added rotations in a given area. If, after remediation, a resident still fails to advance sufficiently on one or more milestones, a CCC might consider extending education, or counseling the resident to consider another specialty or profession.
- While the PD is part of the CCC meeting, the PD must not chair the meeting and can be available for clarification, etc..
- The program director has final responsibility for the program and trainees’ evaluation and promotion.
- The program director reports the aggregate, de-identified information for all residents in the program to the ACGME in the ADS system.
To view the members of the CCCs, please go to individual programs' website
View the Roles and Responsibilities of the CCC